[MiDan]

I have used the 16-85 VR over many years, but personally I would prefer the Sigma nowadays if I had to make the choice.


However, you can't really go wrong with any of the two lenses for your intended purpose. The Nikon offers a wider focal range, while the Sigma's close-focus abilities can be handy at times.


If you got for the Sigma, make sure to get the latest edition of the Sigma lens (the "Contemporary" one).


-- Markus

 

Is the older version of Sigma, the "Contemporany" adds more then 100 Euro to the budget. The quality of the new lens justifies the prices diference ?

Also I'm not sure my photographic skills deserves that ammount of money, at least at this momment.

 

I was tempted by the wider focal range but you are right, close-focus abilities can be more useful, also Sigma could be better for portraits


Thank you,

Daniel