09-21-2010, 12:01 PM
[quote name='Brightcolours' timestamp='1285070014' post='3050']
According to your test data (and that of Klaus), the lenses perform equally well. Why do you rate the Nikon half a star more, don't you guys try to rate in a similar manner?
[/quote]
That half star is mostly for the better bokeh of the Nikkor.
In the field, though, there's probably not really much of a difference between the two, that's why it got the same rating as the Canon (4 stars).
-- Markus
According to your test data (and that of Klaus), the lenses perform equally well. Why do you rate the Nikon half a star more, don't you guys try to rate in a similar manner?
[/quote]
That half star is mostly for the better bokeh of the Nikkor.
In the field, though, there's probably not really much of a difference between the two, that's why it got the same rating as the Canon (4 stars).
-- Markus
Editor
opticallimits.com
opticallimits.com