+- Opticallimits (https://forum.opticallimits.com)
+-- Forum: Forums (https://forum.opticallimits.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Just Talk (https://forum.opticallimits.com/forumdisplay.php?fid=17)
+--- Thread: Quality Panel Advice (/showthread.php?tid=3349)
Quality Panel Advice - Guest - 03-04-2011
Hi All,
I am in seach of a new display. Primary purpose photo editing (I consider myself a prosumer), will use Lightroom/ Photoshop, am working on a Mac (i.e. color managed environment w/ DisplayPort possibility), cannot calibrate yet but want to learn it. As for size, I think 24" is target, 22" is OK and 27" may be too big (will be sitting close to the display).
I do not print my own photos but rather send them to a professional printer.
Secondary use office work, i.e. need text to be well legible. No movie watching (i.e. 16:10 is likely my choice, panel speed is not relevant).
Want the diplay to keep me happy for the next 4-5 years, which is why I am willing to shell out something around EUR 1000 (will be buing in Europe).
Having done some research, I came up with the following choices and queries, with which I would appreciate your kind advice:
- Eizo CG223W and NEC MultiSync PA241W seem to correspond to what I am looking for
? do not know if this is not an overkill (it seems lot of prosumers are perfectly happy with less expensive choices such as Dell U2711)
? is there really a problem with font antialiasing in Mac OS X when using PVA panel
? is it a hype or truth that PVA panels cannot display dark gray gradients when viewed directly, is there a problem in that colors on the edge of the screen already fade when screen is viewed directly
? what about the violet-glare problem with IPS panel
? do I need colorimeter straight away to get the monitor colors right, how often do I need to calibrate
I know this may be a bit chaotic. I will appreciate if you tell me your personal experience/ point me in the right direction.
Thank you
Ed
Quality Panel Advice - Guest - 03-05-2011
Ed,
I can only reply/comment on part of your questions:
I have an Eizo S2031W. It is smaller (20") and from a "cheaper" series than the CG223W. I use it in a way similar to what you mention. It is perfectly adequate for me. The CG223W might be a bit more than you need. But if you can afford it...
My Eizo needs hardly any calibration, in the sense that I see very little difference when I calibrate it with my Spyder3. But mine isn't a "wide color gamut" model, and I have heard that those that are, _do_ require calibration for proper colors.
Thomas
Quality Panel Advice - Guest - 03-07-2011
Thomas,
Many thanks for your input.
Ed
[quote name='ThomasAM' timestamp='1299343112' post='6530']
Ed,
I can only reply/comment on part of your questions:
I have an Eizo S2031W. It is smaller (20") and from a "cheaper" series than the CG223W. I use it in a way similar to what you mention. It is perfectly adequate for me. The CG223W might be a bit more than you need. But if you can afford it...
My Eizo needs hardly any calibration, in the sense that I see very little difference when I calibrate it with my Spyder3. But mine isn't a "wide color gamut" model, and I have heard that those that are, _do_ require calibration for proper colors.
Thomas
[/quote]