01-17-2012, 03:29 PM
[quote name='mst' timestamp='1326791894' post='14944']
I have strong doubts we should provide something like this. Even a sorted listing per test section already puts too much emphasis on the star rating IMO. …..
-- Markus
[/quote]
…. wouldn't want a system to look bad now, ahem nikon -
anyhow, dare i suggest that this star chart thingy is a tad simplistic, is it not dumbing down all the subtle test words and charts to just a star or five ….. don't the nuances of the whole test go missing ….. are we all too slow to actually read and look up alternatives, or ask on the forum if we don't know, isn't that what this place is all about - or -
and urm, is it a problem that 4/3rd's will simply disappear altogether ….
…..still, stars are probably a place to start i suppose …. after which flash ads all across the top and down the sides will no doubt draw the fans in, just like other popularly sucessful percentage places
I have strong doubts we should provide something like this. Even a sorted listing per test section already puts too much emphasis on the star rating IMO. …..
-- Markus
[/quote]
…. wouldn't want a system to look bad now, ahem nikon -
anyhow, dare i suggest that this star chart thingy is a tad simplistic, is it not dumbing down all the subtle test words and charts to just a star or five ….. don't the nuances of the whole test go missing ….. are we all too slow to actually read and look up alternatives, or ask on the forum if we don't know, isn't that what this place is all about - or -
and urm, is it a problem that 4/3rd's will simply disappear altogether ….
…..still, stars are probably a place to start i suppose …. after which flash ads all across the top and down the sides will no doubt draw the fans in, just like other popularly sucessful percentage places