[Brightcolours]

Next time you'd better check PZ's own statements before speaking in their name, Brightcolours:

You have to read and try to understand what it all means. YOU were the one trying to compare the numbers, while PZ explains exactly there why that is not a good idea. So... Yeah. You read it again.

To be read here

 

I try to avoid becoming personal, BC,

Coming from you, that is rich. Now I wonder where in my post i got "personal".

but I put it in this way: I do trust lensrentals a couple of times more than your reasoning.

Oh well. If you think it is faulty reasoning to suggest to test the SAME lens on the two different cameras.. what can I say. Only that way you know which part of the results is due to the different camera.

Their, and especially Roger's, comments do make sense to me. While your reasoning appears to me from of a different world with some special optic rules. So, no, nothing of your last post will sink in.

Do you really and seriously believe, the lack of AA filters leads to an increase of 20% MTF values? And if you think, putting an adaptor in between lens and body is a good way to compare lenses - why don't you do it yourself? Lenstesting is time consuming and lensrentals runs a main business and a very informative blog - with enough experience, Imatest and optical benches. Trying to bring them into discredit leads only to discredit your own posts in my eyes.

Oh well.