05-04-2012, 08:50 PM
[quote name='Frank' timestamp='1336058624' post='17978']
How is this zoom lens? The lens seems to have a very good reputation among users. Many people have talked about the very low distortion which is only seen in the range of 28-35mm and beyond which distortion is hardly seen. This character seems very remarkable among zoom lenses in this FL range.
A used copy of this lens has a very good price, so I have a desire to buy one. But I want to know sharpness wise how this lens is compared to the AF-D 24-85mm f2.8-4. Are they similar or is one better than the other?
I also want to know the comparison of this lens to the AF-S 24-120mm f4 VR (also sharpness wise). I know the latter is much more modern but from the test results at PZ I don't think its IQ justifies its high price.
Thank you for opinions in advance.
Best regards,
Frank
[/quote]
These are very good remarks. I suppose you're considering using them on a fullframe body (otherwise it wouldn't make sense). I'm in the same boat as you. Unfortunately PZ only tested them (28-105 and 24-85) on a D200 which is far from being representative of their performance on a FF body.
As I found the IQ of the recent 24-120 f4 not that fantastic from the review here (especially given its price point), I decided to buy a 28-105 for testing purposes. As I got it for $140 I'm not taking much risk. I wanted to also get a 24-85 f2.8-4 as I value more the 4mm at the wide end and the brightness than the 20mm at the long end. However, I couldn't find any at a comparable price (they were all > $300).
From the PZ reviews both of these lenses fare very well though. I'd be curious to see how they fare on a D3X or a D800...
As soon as I get my D800 (should be on May 31st), I'll let you know how the 28-105 behaves!
How is this zoom lens? The lens seems to have a very good reputation among users. Many people have talked about the very low distortion which is only seen in the range of 28-35mm and beyond which distortion is hardly seen. This character seems very remarkable among zoom lenses in this FL range.
A used copy of this lens has a very good price, so I have a desire to buy one. But I want to know sharpness wise how this lens is compared to the AF-D 24-85mm f2.8-4. Are they similar or is one better than the other?
I also want to know the comparison of this lens to the AF-S 24-120mm f4 VR (also sharpness wise). I know the latter is much more modern but from the test results at PZ I don't think its IQ justifies its high price.
Thank you for opinions in advance.
Best regards,
Frank
[/quote]
These are very good remarks. I suppose you're considering using them on a fullframe body (otherwise it wouldn't make sense). I'm in the same boat as you. Unfortunately PZ only tested them (28-105 and 24-85) on a D200 which is far from being representative of their performance on a FF body.
As I found the IQ of the recent 24-120 f4 not that fantastic from the review here (especially given its price point), I decided to buy a 28-105 for testing purposes. As I got it for $140 I'm not taking much risk. I wanted to also get a 24-85 f2.8-4 as I value more the 4mm at the wide end and the brightness than the 20mm at the long end. However, I couldn't find any at a comparable price (they were all > $300).
From the PZ reviews both of these lenses fare very well though. I'd be curious to see how they fare on a D3X or a D800...
As soon as I get my D800 (should be on May 31st), I'll let you know how the 28-105 behaves!