11-26-2010, 10:46 AM
[quote name='Class A' timestamp='1290767877' post='4463']
I think you are right with your "going well into the false positive realm" comment, but don't quite understand why you regard it as "subjective" rather than "inappropriate"?
Do we agree that there is no point in looking for false detail and that this means that the K10D figure is inflated? I don't think we should be looking into pushing the K-5 figure but rather bringing down the K10D figure. Agreed?
I still think there is some clarification needed as to whether we are talking about B&W LW/PH in the case of the K10D or not.
[/quote]
Well I think if your going to use visual assessment of the resoltuion then it will always be subjective you will tend to see what you wish to see to prove/disprove your point.
Given these test charts are designed to allow computational assessment I'm surprised that more 'review' sites don't use this objective method.
Though I think Klaus's figure is to high I do accept his right to set the bar where he sees fit, But that bar should really remain constant for all cameras and not slide around to fit the story at the time.
I think you are right with your "going well into the false positive realm" comment, but don't quite understand why you regard it as "subjective" rather than "inappropriate"?
Do we agree that there is no point in looking for false detail and that this means that the K10D figure is inflated? I don't think we should be looking into pushing the K-5 figure but rather bringing down the K10D figure. Agreed?
I still think there is some clarification needed as to whether we are talking about B&W LW/PH in the case of the K10D or not.
[/quote]
Well I think if your going to use visual assessment of the resoltuion then it will always be subjective you will tend to see what you wish to see to prove/disprove your point.
Given these test charts are designed to allow computational assessment I'm surprised that more 'review' sites don't use this objective method.
Though I think Klaus's figure is to high I do accept his right to set the bar where he sees fit, But that bar should really remain constant for all cameras and not slide around to fit the story at the time.