11-02-2010, 11:09 AM
Mostly I agree with you... In fact, I'd like to make this kind of test for D300 and D700, since there are no major differences effecting the IQ except for the sensor and pixel size (same metering sensor, both have 14 bit A/D convertion, both allow uncompressed data production etc...). So, this would show meaningful differences concerning the topic we discuss here (sensor area & pixel size), if there are any.
OTOH, I believe that, theory vs. praxis is the wrong way to criticise the discussion here. Rather than that "theory with praxis", so that the statements and arguements can be objective and concrete. Because the IQ is always subjective in the end (my eyes, my LCD screen, my color conception, my noise tolerance etc...), and thus must be supported with the theory.
Kind regards,
Serkan
OTOH, I believe that, theory vs. praxis is the wrong way to criticise the discussion here. Rather than that "theory with praxis", so that the statements and arguements can be objective and concrete. Because the IQ is always subjective in the end (my eyes, my LCD screen, my color conception, my noise tolerance etc...), and thus must be supported with the theory.
Kind regards,
Serkan